top of page

The U.S. Prison System & Neo-Slavery

22 hours ago
5 min read

KWAME A. FORDJOUR, Staff Writer

On July 4, we commemorated the 250th anniversary of the United States, celebrating the day when the newly founded nation had first set its vision of freedom into a declaration for its independence. It established that, “all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.” However, somewhere between the time they made this vow they began a change, a change that may have gone against everything America was supposed to stand for. 

On December 6, 1865, the U.S ratified the 13th Amendment, “abolishing” slavery and freeing the thousands of enslaved Africans in the south. You would think this is where it would stop; no one would be forced to labor against their will, and they would be free to choose what they did for work, when they worked, and for how long. However, this was far from reality. 

Although the 13th Amendment was ratified to abolish slavery and involuntary servitude it made one note that would shift the way slavery was implemented in the U.S. The first section of the 13th Amendment states that, “Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime.” “Except as punishment for crime” opened the door towards the exploitation of a new minority in America: convicts, renewing the institution of slavery in the U.S, only now under a different name. Prison.

Let us start with the introduction of neo-slavery in the work force, before transitioning to its implementation into the prison system. In the same year of the 13th Amendment passed, a series of “Black Codes” were enacted across southern states, leading to the beginning of the neo-slavery movement in the work force. An article from History.com explains that, “Black people who broke labor contracts were subject to arrest, beating and forced labor, and apprenticeship laws forced many minors (either orphans or those whose parents were deemed unable to support them by a judge) into unpaid labor for white planters.” This illustrates the exploitation of newly freed African-Americans into the same system they were trying to escape. To further this movement in the U.S prison system, they would use black codes in other ways to essentially re-enslave black people, utilizing discriminatory vagrancy laws, laws that arrested the unemployed and or the unhoused, in the black codes to specifically target African-Americans and similar minorities for “minor infractions." 

A system of penal labor known as convict leasing was established at this time. Black men convicted for vagrancy would be used as unpaid laborers. As stated by the VCU Libraries, Social Welfare History Project in an article titled Jim Crow Laws and Racial Segregation.

The system of convict leasing was legally outlawed after some time in 1941, however, future fair labor acts still didn’t solve the problem of forced prison labor, nor did it prevent the prison system from forcing convicts to work for private companies, it just furthered the divide between prisoner laborers and free workers. 

In an article by Nina Mast, titled Forced prison labor in the “Land of the Free,” she states that “In seven Southern states—Alabama, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Mississippi, South Carolina, and Texas—almost all work by prisoners remains unpaid… Though incarcerated people work long hours and perform labor-intensive and even deadly work for the benefit of government at all levels, they are excluded from the rights and protections afforded to most workers—including overtime pay, protection from discrimination, and the right to collectively bargain over wages and workplace conditions.” Both the situations from the 1860s and those today look eerily similar, giving way to the same practices that lead to fundamental rights being stripped away in exchange for economic return for the United States. 

In the article, “You’re His Property’: How One Sheriff Used Inmate Labor on His Family Farm,“ by Steph Quinn, Mukta Joshi, and Jerry Mitchell of The New York Times, "around 2020, a Mississippi sheriff named Bryan Bailey used inmate labor on his personal, family farm to extract profit, using tax-payer funded equipment.” Several inmates stated they “felt intense pressure to do whatever was asked of them without complaint.” With increasing stress from the document they signed stating that they had to “accept the maximum sentence for their crimes if they were ‘removed from the program for any reason.’” The prisoners in these types of programs were rarely paid well if at all and forced into working long hours with no recourse without the threat of lengthy imprisonment. 

These inmates have limited agency in working in states where neo-slavery prison labor systems exist as convict “leasing,” although not formally called that anymore (now called trusties), it is a system that will always inherently include a power imbalance between inmate and officer.

NBTHS Assistant Principal and Social Studies Supervisor, Mark Zielinski, shared his thoughts on the issues that came with this side of the 13th Amendment, acknowledging the troubles the system has in our modern society. He stated, “Different scholars and activists bring up issues of mass incarceration and the way that our incarceration system has become more profit-oriented. It's become something that is a really important issue […] the 13th Amendment loophole is something that we really need to reassess, not only in and of itself, but in the greater context of incarceration in our country, the purpose of it, the techniques that are used, and the end result that is desired.”

It is becoming harder to separate the U.S prison experience economically as well as in a rehabilitative sense and as America continues to grow and change we question if this method of penitentiary discipline is appropriate or archaic in the 21st century. 

Zielinski continued his thoughts when he explained, “If incarceration does not rehabilitate people or help them to understand their choices and to make better choices [or] have better opportunities, then in contrast it actually puts them deeper in a hole economically and doesn't help them fix other parts of their lives. It would seem almost foolish to think that those patterns are going to change after that person gets out.”

Just because someone was incarcerated does not make them less than human, nor does it mean they should be subject to indentured servitude or slavery. The penitentiary system should work to better the people that find themselves inside it, not exploit them. Allowing these systems to continue and influence other systems of the U.S is how basic civil rights are slowly pushed to the side in favor of economic and political gain. Freedom from abuse and forced labor should not only be the fundamental right of the free but to every single citizen of a nation that once prided itself on freedom and equality. 


Comments


bottom of page